Hermione's
being wrong all the time in
HBP.... why?
**A HBP theory**
Many of you all wondered why the
heck Hermione was wrong about
EVERYTHING in Half Blood Prince.
Think of her not knowing
anything in Potions. She
was wrong about Malfoy (she has
NEVER been wrong, remember).
She was wrong about Snape.
She criticized Harry for
everything, even if he was
right.
But why was she so inept now?
Has she finally leveled out in
smarts? Is she now as
correct as Ron (who is wrong ALL
the time)? My theory is
no. JKR couldn't have this
female genius suddenly not know
the answers.
My theory involves Merope,
who was Voldemort's mom. I
know, you're thinking, "Why
would I even attach those two
together?" But Merope,
whose man that she loved left
her before she had her child,
went into a depressed slump
before dying and having Voldie.
Merope was a witch. She
could easily just use her magic
to make herself better, which is
what both Harry and Voldie had
pondered. But Dumbledore
knew the answer; Merope was
heartbroken, and felt no need to
live. She let go of her
powers, even though she was
perfectly capable of doing
magic.
What does this have to do
with Hermione? Well, one:
Hermione suddenly can't do
anything right. This is a
sudden thing. Two:
Harry likes Ginny. Another
sudden thing. Perhaps
Hermione is feeling heartbroken,
too. Her love of her life
is going out with her friend,
and Hermione feels horrible,
wronged, and just overall awful.
She starts snapping at people
who she has never snapped at
before (like Ginny, for
instance). And her powers
are decreasing.
I hope that Hermione reveals
her feelings to Harry before she
ends up like Merope...